Addison Barger's decision to rely on pitching over hitting is a rookie mistake that will cost him and the team.

Some might argue that playing it safe by pitching allows Bregar time to adjust without risking injury or poor performance at bat. But when you’re a high-profile player returning from an absence, every moment counts in terms of building confidence and momentum—both things this decision seems likely to undermine.

Barger risks damaging his reputation as both players and fans might see him ducking challenges rather than facing them head-on.

As seasons progress, this decision could come back to haunt Bregar if he can’t hit when called upon later in games or during crucial moments of the season. It sets a dangerous precedent where talent alone isn't enough; savvy management plays into player performance too.

Fans and critics will split sharply over whether they think this move is prudent for career longevity versus detrimental to immediate team success. Those who see it as sensible might overlook Bregar’s struggles at bat, while others could view his strategy with skepticism or even disdain.